Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 9 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 9 & 10 (Known as AST)
Part 1: Summary
Chapter 9 in CIW discusses the advantages and disadvantages of inductive and deductive thinking. Marzano identifies that both are successful in yielding higher understanding with students but isolates deductive thinking as a more effective practice. He continues by asserting that hypothesizing is a powerful way to promote higher levels of thinking, and therefore ownership of learning on the part of the students. By allowing students to generate their own hypotheses, you allow the students to create a problem based more on what interests them about a topic of study rather than assigning them what you want to grade. This strategy really delves into the students’ own methodologies and thought processes. In this manner, students are able to invent, experiment, and problem solve based on their own ideas. The beauty of this method is that they are motivated to find issues to problems they come up with.
Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 9 in AST deals with connecting with all students equally. As it relates to chapter 9 in CIW, I think that for a teacher to be in tune with all students will promote the greatest amount of self-motivation for all students. Low achieving students should be equally tended to (if not more so). What paying closer attention does is give students the approval that they seldom get as a result of poor study habits, intuition or inventiveness. Because a hypothesis is a logical or education assumption or supposition, no student will be wrong. This position gives the teacher a unique ability to encourage those who are low achiever into developing a longer lasting knowledge by what they have come up with.
Part 3: Application of learned information – (Dr. Cartwright, I am not in Clinicals this semester).
One thing that I thought was especially poignant in this chapter is that it is VERY difficult to remove your first impressions. As an experienced teacher, PLEASE, pay attention to how you treat and perceive your students. It can make or break the success of an at risk student like no tomorrow! OK, off my soap box. Other than that, I think that hypotheses are a great way to enhance deeper understanding, but should be used to truly enhance the lessons of a unit. As Marzano depicts, it seems that quite a bit of knowledge about a subject should be known in order to make hypothesizing valuable. It seems that to ask students to hypothesize about what they don’t know much about is counterintuitive. Instead, an advance organizer could prime them for creating a hypothesis about what they are going to learn, and then they could mold that hypothesis throughout the unit, with the culminating assessment being the formulation of the hypothesis from start to finish, showing where students have eliminated variables because of new knowledge. In doing this, they can then take a truly robust hypothesis which will make them think deeply about the unit rather than just touch on surface or just ‘good to know’ information.
Monday, November 15, 2010
Sunday, November 7, 2010
Chapter 10
Jorge Romero
Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 10 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 7 & 8 (Know as AST)
Part 1: Summary
Chapter 10 of CIW spoke about the importance of practices that students should try before they engage in learning about a topic. By use of cuing, questions and advance organizers, the teacher can seek out what students already know before they actually take on the day’s lesson or activity. Marzano emphasizes that teachers can use this knowledge as a ‘springboard’ towards like information that serves to connect the unknown with the already known. Marzano also writes about the pauses necessary for teachers to allow students to answer a question that is posed to them. This wait time will allow the students to formulate their answers and not feel like immediate regurgitation of information is necessary. Also, it gives time for students to interact during the questioning process because of the pause before the teacher replies. Marzano also describes the use of advance organizers to give students a ‘heads up’ when going into a new situation. In using the advance organizers, teachers can help students to understand how the topic works without knowing much about it, as in the case of the tornado or career fair.
Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
In effect, the techniques that Marzano emphasizes in chapter 10 of CIW fall into place well with the beliefs in chapter 8 of AST. For example, reframing does not need only apply to student behavior as described in AST. It can apply to helping students extrapolate information they already know but do not know how to describe it. If a student rattles off information about a topic, it could be easily dismissed as wrong if the teacher does not take the time to interpret what the student is saying. The main tie between the two chapters is that the teacher must get to know the student in order to understand the meaning behind the words when the words don’t quite make sense. Marzano covers this specific topic in a subheading ‘Engage in behaviors that shows affection for each student.” By understanding that a student is taking a risk by declaring a piece of information about a topic that has not yet been reinforced, the teacher must also acknowledge that the student will need support and understanding. This means that if the student is wrong, isolate the portion that is wrong but encourage the line of thinking on the rest of the statement.
Part 3: Application of learned information – (Dr. Cartwright, I am not in clinicals this semester).
I must admit, questioning is one of my weaknesses. Questioning is extremely important when it comes to the learning process. An old adage concerning the structure of the class is: “You tell them what you’re going to tell them, then you tell them, then you tell them what you told them.” One of the problems with this is that it doesn’t ever say, “Ask them to tell you.” For several consecutive reviews, my principal would tell me that the lesson was solid but my questioning technique needed improvement. I would add more questions, but my principal would say the same thing. The problem was that I wasn’t calling on any one student for the answer, so I was leaving the more quiet students alone while the more extroverted students were answering all of the questions. I received a good review when I began using the questioning technique of wait time. This way, I would call on a student and wait for the response, thus engaging a different student with each question. One of the oddities about this questioning method is that when I started, I felt like I was wasting time waiting so long for the students to answer my questions. After awhile, I noticed that the students felt less pressured to answer immediately, and they could ease into the right answer. Another positive aspect of this was that it helped tremendously with my questioning technique. I learned to ask more important questions rather than abstract questions more appropriate for writing responses.
Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 10 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 7 & 8 (Know as AST)
Part 1: Summary
Chapter 10 of CIW spoke about the importance of practices that students should try before they engage in learning about a topic. By use of cuing, questions and advance organizers, the teacher can seek out what students already know before they actually take on the day’s lesson or activity. Marzano emphasizes that teachers can use this knowledge as a ‘springboard’ towards like information that serves to connect the unknown with the already known. Marzano also writes about the pauses necessary for teachers to allow students to answer a question that is posed to them. This wait time will allow the students to formulate their answers and not feel like immediate regurgitation of information is necessary. Also, it gives time for students to interact during the questioning process because of the pause before the teacher replies. Marzano also describes the use of advance organizers to give students a ‘heads up’ when going into a new situation. In using the advance organizers, teachers can help students to understand how the topic works without knowing much about it, as in the case of the tornado or career fair.
Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
In effect, the techniques that Marzano emphasizes in chapter 10 of CIW fall into place well with the beliefs in chapter 8 of AST. For example, reframing does not need only apply to student behavior as described in AST. It can apply to helping students extrapolate information they already know but do not know how to describe it. If a student rattles off information about a topic, it could be easily dismissed as wrong if the teacher does not take the time to interpret what the student is saying. The main tie between the two chapters is that the teacher must get to know the student in order to understand the meaning behind the words when the words don’t quite make sense. Marzano covers this specific topic in a subheading ‘Engage in behaviors that shows affection for each student.” By understanding that a student is taking a risk by declaring a piece of information about a topic that has not yet been reinforced, the teacher must also acknowledge that the student will need support and understanding. This means that if the student is wrong, isolate the portion that is wrong but encourage the line of thinking on the rest of the statement.
Part 3: Application of learned information – (Dr. Cartwright, I am not in clinicals this semester).
I must admit, questioning is one of my weaknesses. Questioning is extremely important when it comes to the learning process. An old adage concerning the structure of the class is: “You tell them what you’re going to tell them, then you tell them, then you tell them what you told them.” One of the problems with this is that it doesn’t ever say, “Ask them to tell you.” For several consecutive reviews, my principal would tell me that the lesson was solid but my questioning technique needed improvement. I would add more questions, but my principal would say the same thing. The problem was that I wasn’t calling on any one student for the answer, so I was leaving the more quiet students alone while the more extroverted students were answering all of the questions. I received a good review when I began using the questioning technique of wait time. This way, I would call on a student and wait for the response, thus engaging a different student with each question. One of the oddities about this questioning method is that when I started, I felt like I was wasting time waiting so long for the students to answer my questions. After awhile, I noticed that the students felt less pressured to answer immediately, and they could ease into the right answer. Another positive aspect of this was that it helped tremendously with my questioning technique. I learned to ask more important questions rather than abstract questions more appropriate for writing responses.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)