Monday, November 15, 2010

Chapter 9

Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 9 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 9 & 10 (Known as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Chapter 9 in CIW discusses the advantages and disadvantages of inductive and deductive thinking. Marzano identifies that both are successful in yielding higher understanding with students but isolates deductive thinking as a more effective practice. He continues by asserting that hypothesizing is a powerful way to promote higher levels of thinking, and therefore ownership of learning on the part of the students. By allowing students to generate their own hypotheses, you allow the students to create a problem based more on what interests them about a topic of study rather than assigning them what you want to grade. This strategy really delves into the students’ own methodologies and thought processes. In this manner, students are able to invent, experiment, and problem solve based on their own ideas. The beauty of this method is that they are motivated to find issues to problems they come up with.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 9 in AST deals with connecting with all students equally. As it relates to chapter 9 in CIW, I think that for a teacher to be in tune with all students will promote the greatest amount of self-motivation for all students. Low achieving students should be equally tended to (if not more so). What paying closer attention does is give students the approval that they seldom get as a result of poor study habits, intuition or inventiveness. Because a hypothesis is a logical or education assumption or supposition, no student will be wrong. This position gives the teacher a unique ability to encourage those who are low achiever into developing a longer lasting knowledge by what they have come up with.

Part 3: Application of learned information – (Dr. Cartwright, I am not in Clinicals this semester).
One thing that I thought was especially poignant in this chapter is that it is VERY difficult to remove your first impressions. As an experienced teacher, PLEASE, pay attention to how you treat and perceive your students. It can make or break the success of an at risk student like no tomorrow! OK, off my soap box. Other than that, I think that hypotheses are a great way to enhance deeper understanding, but should be used to truly enhance the lessons of a unit. As Marzano depicts, it seems that quite a bit of knowledge about a subject should be known in order to make hypothesizing valuable. It seems that to ask students to hypothesize about what they don’t know much about is counterintuitive. Instead, an advance organizer could prime them for creating a hypothesis about what they are going to learn, and then they could mold that hypothesis throughout the unit, with the culminating assessment being the formulation of the hypothesis from start to finish, showing where students have eliminated variables because of new knowledge. In doing this, they can then take a truly robust hypothesis which will make them think deeply about the unit rather than just touch on surface or just ‘good to know’ information.

Sunday, November 7, 2010

Chapter 10

Jorge Romero
Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 10 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 7 & 8 (Know as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Chapter 10 of CIW spoke about the importance of practices that students should try before they engage in learning about a topic. By use of cuing, questions and advance organizers, the teacher can seek out what students already know before they actually take on the day’s lesson or activity. Marzano emphasizes that teachers can use this knowledge as a ‘springboard’ towards like information that serves to connect the unknown with the already known. Marzano also writes about the pauses necessary for teachers to allow students to answer a question that is posed to them. This wait time will allow the students to formulate their answers and not feel like immediate regurgitation of information is necessary. Also, it gives time for students to interact during the questioning process because of the pause before the teacher replies. Marzano also describes the use of advance organizers to give students a ‘heads up’ when going into a new situation. In using the advance organizers, teachers can help students to understand how the topic works without knowing much about it, as in the case of the tornado or career fair.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
In effect, the techniques that Marzano emphasizes in chapter 10 of CIW fall into place well with the beliefs in chapter 8 of AST. For example, reframing does not need only apply to student behavior as described in AST. It can apply to helping students extrapolate information they already know but do not know how to describe it. If a student rattles off information about a topic, it could be easily dismissed as wrong if the teacher does not take the time to interpret what the student is saying. The main tie between the two chapters is that the teacher must get to know the student in order to understand the meaning behind the words when the words don’t quite make sense. Marzano covers this specific topic in a subheading ‘Engage in behaviors that shows affection for each student.” By understanding that a student is taking a risk by declaring a piece of information about a topic that has not yet been reinforced, the teacher must also acknowledge that the student will need support and understanding. This means that if the student is wrong, isolate the portion that is wrong but encourage the line of thinking on the rest of the statement.

Part 3: Application of learned information – (Dr. Cartwright, I am not in clinicals this semester).
I must admit, questioning is one of my weaknesses. Questioning is extremely important when it comes to the learning process. An old adage concerning the structure of the class is: “You tell them what you’re going to tell them, then you tell them, then you tell them what you told them.” One of the problems with this is that it doesn’t ever say, “Ask them to tell you.” For several consecutive reviews, my principal would tell me that the lesson was solid but my questioning technique needed improvement. I would add more questions, but my principal would say the same thing. The problem was that I wasn’t calling on any one student for the answer, so I was leaving the more quiet students alone while the more extroverted students were answering all of the questions. I received a good review when I began using the questioning technique of wait time. This way, I would call on a student and wait for the response, thus engaging a different student with each question. One of the oddities about this questioning method is that when I started, I felt like I was wasting time waiting so long for the students to answer my questions. After awhile, I noticed that the students felt less pressured to answer immediately, and they could ease into the right answer. Another positive aspect of this was that it helped tremendously with my questioning technique. I learned to ask more important questions rather than abstract questions more appropriate for writing responses.

Monday, October 25, 2010

Chapter 7 in CIW

Jorge Romero
Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 7 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 5 & 6 (Known as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Chapter 7 in CIW deals with the efficacy of group and cooperative learning. Marzano asserts that this method of learning can be very beneficial for students, especially when students are grouped in heterogeneous groups. This means that their group consists of students of different abilities. One aspect that I did like was the description of how a teacher would decide on the groups on the basis of some seemingly random criteria, like the type of pets that one has. This allows for a random division of students which levels the playing field by allowing for student ability to not be a factor in group creation. One of the more interesting points that Marzano makes comes at the end of the chapter where he demonstrates the limitations of cooperative learning. The example he uses is an overzealous teacher who tries to make all lesson cooperative. The students cry foul in that they want some time to learn on their own.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 6 in AST deals with classroom organization and procedures. One aspect that Marzano illustrates with a diagram is the layout of a typical classroom. With some classes, the classical ‘students face forward’ design might be beneficial, but with a more constructivist and cooperative setting, the class may be better laid out in clusters of desks, or even a U. This will help to encourage eye contact between students and therefore encourage participation from all. However, in a cooperative setting, there must be different rules than in a strictly ‘face forward’ type of setting. One must take into account that it will expose the students more to having their opinions challenged, and it is up to the teacher to make sure no feelings get hurt. Chapter 6 describes some of the safeguards that must be taken to ensure that a safe emotional environment be kept, as it is just as important as a physically safe environment.

Part 3: Application of learned information – (Dr. Cartwright, I am not in Clinicals this semester).
All I can say about group projects is that the can be very frustrating for students who have experienced little more than the lecture format of teaching. I conducted a group learning activity in my computer repair classroom. Leading up to this, the students had built computers (one computer per group of four students). The afternoon before the co-op project, I sabotaged their computers. So the group projects were to set in motion, and students would have to solve the issue collectively with their groups. They had internet access, textbooks, and the teacher (me) as resources. I was considered the “expert”. They were given a mock $300 with which to ‘pay’ me for my expertise, each question ranging from $50 to $150. Other than that, they had to solve the issue as a group. The most frustrating part of this activity was that some student became frustrated with little effort. There were a couple of occasions where they just up and quit while their group mates continued. I guess what I am saying is that no matter how much planning you put into any type of lesson; there will always be a few students who will buck the system. In my case, most students did learn something from the experience, but there were those sour apples who didn’t participate, even after encouragement. After talking to them, they basically asked for a lecture situation because they felt they weren’t learning this way.

Monday, October 11, 2010

Chapter 4 in CIW

Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 4 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 5 & 6 (Known as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Chapter 4 in CIW addressed the pros and cons of recognizing student achievement. One of the main items that Marzano writes about is intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation for students. Intrinsic would be self-motivating factors and extrinsic would be motivation from others, whether teachers, rewards, or parents. These motivations help to identify different attributions to their success, as Marzano outline, ability, effort, luck and other people. One of the aspects that Marzano emphasizes is the need to teach self-motivation to students so that they may reap the benefits of learning for themselves and not because the CSOs or teachers require them to. He uses the example of Olympic athletes to demonstrate how self-motivation is a powerful tool, and how it can be useful for whatever we endeavor. What this also entails is for teachers to give appropriate feedback and recognition for students. Marzano states that several studies have identified extrinsic motivators (i.e. money, candy, tangible rewards) as potentially demotivating to students in that they only accomplish a task for minor, superficial recognition. The strongest recognition was the verbal, encouraging, and autonomy supporting recognition.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 5 in AST discusses way to engage students in the lessons. To engage the students is to think “how do I motivate them?” Marzano outlines several methods for instilling motivation through engaging strategies. These include mild pressure, mild controversy, missing information, the self-system, and high energy. By using these strategies, the students can assume a position of knowledge (or what they already know) and can therefore show motivation in wanting to share. In addition, a good teacher mediator will be able to encourage good ideas through verbal and nonverbal communication so that students are aware that they are going in the right direction or that they are making poignant remarks about the topics of discussion.

Part 3: Application of learned information
I am very interested in the topic of motivation amongst science students. What I have found already is that students can be interested in a subject, but if they do not connect with the teacher, that interest remains hidden behind a wall of mistrust, or worse, apathy. It is extremely important to identify with the students through an exchange of recognitions, for which each should be tailored to fit the individual student, and not a blanket ‘well done’ response. This connection with the students often becomes the most important driving factor behind quality learning. For example, it is very difficult to learn in an environment where one is confused. It is more difficult to learn in an environment when one is confused and has had not recognition for periods of enlightenment, or at the very least, recognition of difficulties in the subject. As a teacher, you learn quickly which students need more recognition than others, but it is important to still recognize all students in their times of worry, doubt, perseverance and triumph. I continue to seek ways to acknowledge students and to seek out ways to connect with them in order to maximize their own intrinsic motivations. After all, no amount of effort on my part will help my students if they are not motivated to learn.

Sunday, October 3, 2010

Chapter 5 in CIW

Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 5 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 5 & 6 (Know as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Marzano addresses the topic of homework in Chapter 5 of CIW. He identifies several studies that show the efficacy of homework, beginning with positive effects in the second grade. He demonstrates that studies show that although second graders may not be immediately benefitting from the homework itself, they are in fact benefitting from the resulting habit of continuing their studies at home. The recommendation that Marzano emphasized, although not completely agreed upon by all experts, is that students should do 10 minutes x their grade level worth of homework every night. However, he qualifies that homework should not be exploratory, but should be used to reinforce that information which students already know. The power behind this methodology is that students will be able to achieve levels of mastery through homework for which there is little or no time in school. This chapter was full of great suggestions for homework, such as establishing guidelines for students and parents to follow for homework procedures, keeping parent involvement to a minimum, and making sure that homework does not interrupt the household routine (i.e. bedtime or dinner etc.). Finally, Marzano did emphasize that homework was much more useful when quality feedback was provided by the teacher, rather than just a grade or score.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 6 in AST discusses the efficacy of maintaining order and logic in the classroom. When students know what to expect from the classroom and the teacher, and likewise know what is expected of themselves, then the whole system runs smoothly. When things are left up in the air with respect to regularity, rules and procedures, then students do not know what is expected of them and aim to stay within lines they end up drawing themselves. A teacher is able to instill the order and discipline beyond the classroom by assigning homework, as mentioned in chapter 5 of CIW. The regularity of homework will help increase their understanding of the material and also help to establish a healthy mindset that work is not over just because the class is done. By assigning homework regularly, and holding the students accountable for the homework, a teacher helps students to develop a habit of increasing their persistence, discipline and overall permanence of knowledge.

Part 3: Application of learned information
I suppose that I have learned firsthand that students just do not like to do homework. In high school, there seemed to be a flowing river of excuses, which could be almost inhibitive to the point of giving up assigning it. I have heard excuses from, “my mom was sick so I had to cook,” “I had to work so I didn’t have time,” to even “It was my three week anniversary with my girlfriend.” Let alone the countless times I heard “I didn’t understand it,” or “I forgot what the assignment was.” I found it difficult to help the students because their excuses are real in their minds. Students would receive zeros or low marks because of the excuses that took them beyond the realm of being students to more adult or just non-educational situations. To help deter students from blowing off assignments, I began sending weekly letters to parents via email keeping them up to date with the class. I would also post the letter on the Internet so others could see what was happening in the class. Parents loved being informed and students learned to appreciate having someone to help them with their discipline at home. What I discovered was that however much discipline and order you can have in the classroom, it has little or no bearing on those students who are not self motivated at home. For me to reach out to the families and the students, beyond the scope of the classroom, really helped to reinforce the habits we were trying to build.

Sunday, September 26, 2010

Chapter 6 in CIW

Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 6 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 5 & 6 (Know as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Chapter 6 of CIW describes the underutilization of nonlinguistic teaching. It begins by identifying that most often teachers will use linguistic skills, whether lecture, reading or otherwise debating or collaborating. This neglects several aspects of learning that could prove to be essential for students in making worthwhile and lasting connections between subjects, topics and seemingly random information. Concept mapping, Cause Effect diagrams, and Time Sequence pattern recognition are three main ways for students to grasp concepts by actually seeing the relationships between several items of the unit, or even cross unit information. By being able to have a diagram rather than just words, students can recall either the information from the diagram or the notes.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 5 in AST describes the importance of engaging the students. I feel this goes hand in hand with the concept of graphical representations of material. A classroom setting can get very boring, very quickly, if it is predominantly lecture, reading and note taking. A boring classroom will have difficulty keeping even the most studious of students engaged. For this reason, a change of pace every so often is crucial to keeping students engaged, and even, dare I say it, entertained. By switching gears to creating a graphic organizer, or going further, by launching into an educational and interactive activity, teachers can help stave off the mundane classroom atmosphere and replace it with one that will enhance student participation. I would even go so far as to say a combination of the fun that could be had with a graphic representation would be ideal. One such approach was the Pyramid game identified in chapter 5 (AST) which is, in itself, a graphic organizer.

Part 3: Application of learned information
I did find several of the ideas in chapter 5 very useful and promising for my own classes. I have used the jeopardy idea several times, and it can be easily created using PowerPoint and run by interactive board or just from the computer. Students did seem to like this, but it does require a good deal of preparation. One of the shortcuts that I used was to create the game using the questions that I addressed on the unit exams (not the identical questions), which would cut down on the need to create a whole slew of new questions, just reword already existing question. This would also give students a means by which they could predetermine how they would do on the exam. Another method for jeopardy was to use it at the beginning of the unit, when students did not know many of the answers. This way, they would get a peek at what they were going to learn. I must admit that I was one of the many teachers who did not emphasize the use of nonlinguistic teaching to the extent that the book suggests. I can see the potential in utilizing this method to a greater degree, but I would like to learn more strategies than the basic nonlinguistic methods that the book (CIW) offers.

Saturday, September 18, 2010

Chapter 3 in CIW

Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 3 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 3 & 4 (Know as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Chapter 3 in CIW describes many different methods for teaching students to utilize note taking and summarization. The emphasis for the chapter is that these two methods of retention are grossly underappreciated and therefore misunderstood by students. Students often lack the appropriate practice to take notes effectively and that when summarizing, they have trouble determining what information is essential, good to know, and extraneous. Marzano, from the research on summarization, creates a basic list to aid teachers in demonstrating appropriate summarization. This list includes deleting, substitution and a main idea. To assist teachers, the chapter continues by illustrating 6 different methods of summarizing that students could use to get the most out of their summarizing experience. Marzano concludes the chapter with note taking. He says that note taking is misunderstood by students where they either end up taking verbatim or too verbose notes, or not enough to even capture main points. He explains teacher prepared notes and student outlines could be essential in helping students to develop good note taking strategies.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 3 in AST describes several aspects for which a teacher might find themselves being able to apply the information in chapter 3 of CIW. To begin, Marzano says that experts recommend that any exploratory homework (non-reinforcing) may be some kind of reading, or non-deductive work. This allows students to complete the homework without having to stress about not understanding new topics or concepts. With this in mind, summarizing reading or note taking could be a very connective method for students to own the assignment. The time taken to consider the information and what is important or extraneous is one way for students to not mindlessly read the information and actually absorb the information. Another use could be with similarities and differences. Good notes and summaries will allow students to revisit past materials. For example, a science teacher may be covering the mammals during one lesson and ask the students to compare mammals and reptiles, which they may have covered weeks before. Notes and summaries will allow students to instantly access this information, thus reinforcing it.

Part 3: Application of learned information
Let me just say, “AMEN” to this chapter! I am a firm believer in note taking for retention and in being able to have important information at your fingertips. One of the beliefs nowadays is that if we do not know the information, we can just look it up on the Internet, or more specifically, our giant summary in cyberspace. But note taking and summarization does not only help students trim unnecessary information; it helps them to formulate conclusions for themselves. This was one of the most frustrating issues that I had as a teacher: the lack of quality note taking. In class, there was an online curriculum that I used to augment the daily lessons, from which I would ask students to take notes. Like Marzano states, most students just do not know how to take notes. What I encountered was verbatim notes or too general notes that did not serve any purpose. Seeing that note taking was getting nowhere, I almost abandoned the whole prospect. But a little “Cindy Lou Who” of a student came up to me and set me straight. “I don’t know how to take notes,” she said. With this painful realization, I set out to show students how to take notes. I must admit, that my methods were crude and probably not so beneficial, mainly because I thought I didn’t need any additional literature for support, but now in retrospect, if I had the information from this chapter, I could have made a lasting impression on my students concerning note taking and summarizing.