Monday, October 25, 2010

Chapter 7 in CIW

Jorge Romero
Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 7 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 5 & 6 (Known as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Chapter 7 in CIW deals with the efficacy of group and cooperative learning. Marzano asserts that this method of learning can be very beneficial for students, especially when students are grouped in heterogeneous groups. This means that their group consists of students of different abilities. One aspect that I did like was the description of how a teacher would decide on the groups on the basis of some seemingly random criteria, like the type of pets that one has. This allows for a random division of students which levels the playing field by allowing for student ability to not be a factor in group creation. One of the more interesting points that Marzano makes comes at the end of the chapter where he demonstrates the limitations of cooperative learning. The example he uses is an overzealous teacher who tries to make all lesson cooperative. The students cry foul in that they want some time to learn on their own.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 6 in AST deals with classroom organization and procedures. One aspect that Marzano illustrates with a diagram is the layout of a typical classroom. With some classes, the classical ‘students face forward’ design might be beneficial, but with a more constructivist and cooperative setting, the class may be better laid out in clusters of desks, or even a U. This will help to encourage eye contact between students and therefore encourage participation from all. However, in a cooperative setting, there must be different rules than in a strictly ‘face forward’ type of setting. One must take into account that it will expose the students more to having their opinions challenged, and it is up to the teacher to make sure no feelings get hurt. Chapter 6 describes some of the safeguards that must be taken to ensure that a safe emotional environment be kept, as it is just as important as a physically safe environment.

Part 3: Application of learned information – (Dr. Cartwright, I am not in Clinicals this semester).
All I can say about group projects is that the can be very frustrating for students who have experienced little more than the lecture format of teaching. I conducted a group learning activity in my computer repair classroom. Leading up to this, the students had built computers (one computer per group of four students). The afternoon before the co-op project, I sabotaged their computers. So the group projects were to set in motion, and students would have to solve the issue collectively with their groups. They had internet access, textbooks, and the teacher (me) as resources. I was considered the “expert”. They were given a mock $300 with which to ‘pay’ me for my expertise, each question ranging from $50 to $150. Other than that, they had to solve the issue as a group. The most frustrating part of this activity was that some student became frustrated with little effort. There were a couple of occasions where they just up and quit while their group mates continued. I guess what I am saying is that no matter how much planning you put into any type of lesson; there will always be a few students who will buck the system. In my case, most students did learn something from the experience, but there were those sour apples who didn’t participate, even after encouragement. After talking to them, they basically asked for a lecture situation because they felt they weren’t learning this way.

1 comment:

  1. I think this was a really good group activity. It's too bad some bad apples spoiled the whole bunch. I wonder if you had a small preparatory lesson on how the group activity was going to run and what was expected out of each student, if things would have run smoother. At least students would be fully aware that participation is not optional.

    ReplyDelete