Monday, October 11, 2010

Chapter 4 in CIW

Classroom Instruction that Works – Marzano – Chapter 4 (Known as CIW)
The Art and Science of Teaching – Marzano - Chapters 5 & 6 (Known as AST)

Part 1: Summary
Chapter 4 in CIW addressed the pros and cons of recognizing student achievement. One of the main items that Marzano writes about is intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation for students. Intrinsic would be self-motivating factors and extrinsic would be motivation from others, whether teachers, rewards, or parents. These motivations help to identify different attributions to their success, as Marzano outline, ability, effort, luck and other people. One of the aspects that Marzano emphasizes is the need to teach self-motivation to students so that they may reap the benefits of learning for themselves and not because the CSOs or teachers require them to. He uses the example of Olympic athletes to demonstrate how self-motivation is a powerful tool, and how it can be useful for whatever we endeavor. What this also entails is for teachers to give appropriate feedback and recognition for students. Marzano states that several studies have identified extrinsic motivators (i.e. money, candy, tangible rewards) as potentially demotivating to students in that they only accomplish a task for minor, superficial recognition. The strongest recognition was the verbal, encouraging, and autonomy supporting recognition.

Part 2: Connection to Secondary Text
Chapter 5 in AST discusses way to engage students in the lessons. To engage the students is to think “how do I motivate them?” Marzano outlines several methods for instilling motivation through engaging strategies. These include mild pressure, mild controversy, missing information, the self-system, and high energy. By using these strategies, the students can assume a position of knowledge (or what they already know) and can therefore show motivation in wanting to share. In addition, a good teacher mediator will be able to encourage good ideas through verbal and nonverbal communication so that students are aware that they are going in the right direction or that they are making poignant remarks about the topics of discussion.

Part 3: Application of learned information
I am very interested in the topic of motivation amongst science students. What I have found already is that students can be interested in a subject, but if they do not connect with the teacher, that interest remains hidden behind a wall of mistrust, or worse, apathy. It is extremely important to identify with the students through an exchange of recognitions, for which each should be tailored to fit the individual student, and not a blanket ‘well done’ response. This connection with the students often becomes the most important driving factor behind quality learning. For example, it is very difficult to learn in an environment where one is confused. It is more difficult to learn in an environment when one is confused and has had not recognition for periods of enlightenment, or at the very least, recognition of difficulties in the subject. As a teacher, you learn quickly which students need more recognition than others, but it is important to still recognize all students in their times of worry, doubt, perseverance and triumph. I continue to seek ways to acknowledge students and to seek out ways to connect with them in order to maximize their own intrinsic motivations. After all, no amount of effort on my part will help my students if they are not motivated to learn.

2 comments:

  1. I believe you are making some great connections with student motivation and recognitions. After receiving individualized recognitions tailored to what gives them a sense of accomplishment and encouragment, students will begin to feel comfortable with their learning environment. I believe students whether consciously or subconsciously want to receive more recognition in order to experience those positive feelings that will drive intrinsic motivation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You make a good point about motivation. The purpose of recognition needs to be to elicit student motivation. The best teacher in the world can't learn the content for the students.

    ReplyDelete